2025-03-16



Rank Propaganda / Thought Policing / World Disordering

  • The real history of free speech — from supreme ideal to poisonous politics

    what exactly do we mean by free speech, and should there be any limits on it? In democracies, we celebrate free expression for good and hard-won reasons. Liberty of conscience is superior to enforced theocracy. The right to voice opinions without being persecuted is a hallmark of free societies as opposed to autocracies; so is the creation of challenging art and literature. Whatever your truths, freedom of expression is a valuable and inspiring ideal. But that doesn’t mean its principles are obvious or absolute. We often assume they must have been clearly established by great thinkers of the past, from Milton to James Madison to George Orwell, and that it’s only in the present that we’ve lost our way. But the real history of free speech is far more interesting — and it illuminates our current predicaments in surprisingly direct ways.

    Different ends require different means. Proper rules are constitutive of free expression: they channel it towards its intended aim. It’s also why conflict over free speech is inevitable. If its purpose is to establish truth, it requires one set of conditions; if democracy, a different set; if to create art or generate amusement, yet others and so on. It is an inherently unstable, contradictory ideal, even before we get to our own differences of opinion. If, by contrast, you regard freedom of expression not as a means to an end but as an end in itself, then you elevate it to the supreme ideal: more important than truth, justice, equity, democracy or any other value. That is not only logically problematic, it also implies that any constraint is wrong. The practical effect of such an outlook is to worsen exactly the serious, age-old problems that premodern societies obsessed over, and that all early theorists of free speech were acutely concerned to avoid: a public sphere full of hatred and slander, the poison of untruth and the politics of demagoguery. Welcome to 2025.

  • Strings Attached: Talking about Russia's agenda for laws in cyberspace

AI Will (Save | Destroy) The World

Space / Boomy Zoomers / UFO

Gubmint / Poilitcks / Law Making

External Security / Militaria / Diplomania

Pox / COVID / BioTerror AgitProp